View Original Article

Federal government spending up $331.6 billion under Carney, budget watchdog says

November 17, 2026 1:59 PM
The Canadian Press

OTTAWA – The parliamentary budget officer is questioning the federal government’s vow to spend less and invest more.

In a series of reports released Tuesday scrutinizing the federal budget, PBO Annette Ryan said the Liberal government’s overall fiscal situation is a bit rosier than the forecast in Ottawa’s last spending update in April.

Improved revenues from better-than-expected economic results and a tailwind of tax dollars from higher global oil prices have improved the government’s bottom line since the spring.

But Ryan said Ottawa has used up 96 per cent of that new fiscal room through fresh spending commitments, instead of meaningfully reducing the deficit.

The PBO projects the cost of federal measures is $331.6 billion higher in the three spending plans tabled so far under Prime Minister Mark Carney.

Some 60 per cent of that spending is reserved for the day-to-day operations of government, the PBO points out — not for the kind of capital spending Carney has promised to prioritize.

“The government promised to spend less to invest more. This budget spends more, invests more and borrows more,” Ryan said in a media statement on Tuesday.

John Fragos, spokesperson for Finance Minster Francois-Philippe Champagne, said of the roughly $150 billion announced in Budget 2026 for new measures, about $90 billion is focused on capital expenditure.

The PBO also acknowledged in Tuesday’s report that the Nov. 5 budget shifts Ottawa’s spending priorities toward capital.

“Even so, most new measures from Budget 2025 onward have gone to day-to-day operations,” the report read.

Fragos said instances in the budget of the government borrowing beyond its means are focused solely on generating future growth and setting the stage for greater investments in Canada.

He also pointed to the government’s fiscal anchors — a declining deficit-to-GDP ratio and a pledge to balance the operating budget — as proof of prudent financial management.

The debt-to-GDP ratio — a fiscal anchor for past Liberal governments — is also on a lower trajectory in Budget 2026.

While the government laid out a path to meet its fiscal anchors in this year’s budget, the PBO warned Tuesday that those margins are narrow.

The PBO says if the deficit is $2 billion higher than Ottawa expects in the next fiscal year, the government will fail to fulfil its pledge to reduce the deficit as a share of the economy.

Ryan has raised concerns about how the government defines capital versus operating spending. That definition matters a lot when determining whether the government is meeting its other fiscal anchor — balancing the operating budget.

In Tuesday’s report, Ryan argued that if the government used more internationally accepted definitions for capital and operating spending, Ottawa would fail to balance its operating budget over the forecast horizon.

“Whether the anchor is met depends on how capital is defined,” the report said.

Ryan’s analysis also attempts to get a sense of the scope of government borrowing beyond the deficit line.

Her report says that total borrowing outlined in Budget 2026 is expected to reach $765 billion over five years — $476 billion more than the cumulative deficit of $289 billion.

Total borrowing includes loans to Crown corporations and the purchase of assets — much of that debt does not appear directly on Ottawa’s balance sheets. Capital investments like military equipment are considered assets and show up in the deficit over time as they depreciate, even though they’re paid for upfront.

In other words, taking out a loan to buy a car might leave you with an asset, but that doesn’t mean you’re not still paying off the loan and interest costs.

The government will have to find that $765 billion whether it adds to the deficit or not — and the PBO notes that the recent Bank of Canada interest rate hike is set to increase borrowing costs for Canadians and governments alike.

Public debt costs are now the fastest-growing line item on a year-over-year basis in the federal budget, Ryan noted during an appearance at the House of Commons’ finance committee on Tuesday. Those costs are expected to become larger than the cost of federal health transfers to provinces in the years to come.

When a government’s spending outpaces revenues, that means taking on debt and pushing the need to cover those costs into the future, Ryan said.

Some of those borrowing costs are paid back through interest on loaned money or returns on investments. But loans can go bad and projects might flounder, so those returns are not guaranteed.

“Investments now in things like military equipment, infrastructure, pipelines, and so on, have these very real costs that will need to be paid back — hopefully from successful projects and greater prosperity,” Ryan told MPs at the committee on Tuesday. “But if not, they still need to be paid back.”

This report by The Canadian Press was first published Nov. 17, 2026.

Sign up for the BOE Report Daily Digest E-mail Return to Home